Services not allowed in MLS - Timeline for MLS Service Support
# Services not allowed in MLS - Timeline for MLS Service Support
## Current Behavior
When attempting to add a service to a team with MLS as the default protocol, we receive the error "Services not allowed in MLS". This is enforced by the `guardMLSNotDefault` check in the service whitelist update logic.
## Expected Behavior
We would like to understand:
1. Is this a temporary limitation or a permanent design decision?
2. If temporary, what is the timeline for supporting services in MLS conversations?
3. Are there any technical challenges preventing services from supporting MLS protocol?
## Technical Context
From the codebase, we can see this limitation is explicitly implemented:
```haskell
guardMLSNotDefault = lift . liftSem $ do
feat <- GalleyAPIAccess.getFeatureConfigForTeam @_ @Feature.MLSConfig tid
let defProtocol = feat.config.mlsDefaultProtocol
case defProtocol of
ProtocolProteusTag -> pure ()
ProtocolMLSTag -> throw UserSubsystemMLSServicesNotAllowed
ProtocolMixedTag -> throw UserSubsystemMLSServicesNotAllowed
```
## Impact
This limitation affects our ability to:
1. Use services in teams that have migrated to MLS
2. Maintain consistent service functionality across different protocol versions
3. Plan our migration strategy to MLS
## Questions
1. Is there an official roadmap for MLS service support?
2. Are there any workarounds we can use in the meantime?
3. Will there be a migration path for existing services when MLS support is added?
## Additional Context
- We are currently using Wire Server version: 5.16.0
Thank you for your time and consideration.
0 条评论