ITADN

"improve-codebase-architecture" skill is terrible after "grill-me" added to it.

#274Openfuzzyhope1502 创建于 2026-05-29
F
fuzzyhope1502commented
I was a huge fan of the "improve-codebase-architecture" originally when it didn't have the grilling section. It was a convenient way to get a thorough analysis of improvements that can be made, as well as exploring those improvements and finding good implementations that weren't overengineered. This skill genuinely felt like magic back then. Now, ever since the "grilling" section has been added to it, it's borderline unusable and just spews completely irrelevant information constantly. You will ask it something very simple like "How can I reduce friction between these 2 modules?", and it will do the explore part no problems, then immediately proposes a single solution, and starts grilling you about it for usually 10's or 100's of questions. The whole point of the skill is to propose ideas in a shotgun blast so I can make the decision myself of "does this solve the problem". Instead I'm now given a 2 hour long interview session about a system that was proposed to me 2 seconds prior and the questions it asks, and it actively attempts to offload basically all work to the user every opportunity it gets. I like both of the "grill-me" and "improve-codebase-architecture" skills individually, but using them together is a headache and I feel it makes the "improve-codebase-architecture" borderline unusable since it's been added. I'd be curious to hear if anyone else is getting this issue. I've completely stopped using this skill ever since this change was made, it's absolutely horrendous. --- I'm not really sure if there is a way I can just get the old version back myself? I've tried using the skills cli but i think it's only capable of downloading the latest ones? Does this mean I need to go find the old one myself, copy it, and make my own local version for it?
3 条评论