# Task Summary: Rubric10-Semantic Issues & Fixes

## Completed Tasks

### ✅ Task 1: Check Rubric10 Evaluation Issues

**Findings documented in**: `RUBRIC10_ISSUES_REPORT.md`

**Major Issues Found**:
1. **Inconsistent JSON structures across all 4 projects**
   - CM4AI: Uses `overall_scores.total_score`
   - AI_READI: Uses `overall_score.total_points`
   - CHORUS: Uses `overall_summary` (no score field)
   - VOICE: Uses `overall_assessment` (no score field)

2. **HTML renderer incompatibility**
   - Renderer expects `summary_scores.total_score`
   - NONE of the current files match this structure
   - Cannot generate HTML from current evaluations

3. **Missing required schema fields**
   - No `rubric`, `version`, `project`, `method` fields
   - No `evaluation_timestamp` or `model` fields
   - Cannot validate with `jsonschema`

**Status**: Much worse than rubric20 (which just had math errors).
**Recommendation**: Complete regeneration required.

### ✅ Task 2: Create Rubric10-Semantic Schema

**Created**: `src/download/prompts/rubric10_semantic_schema.json`

**Key Features**:
- Aligned with `rubric10_output_format.json` example
- Compatible with HTML renderer expectations
- Matches rubric20 schema structure for consistency
- Includes all required fields (rubric, version, project, method, timestamp, model)
- Specifies `summary_scores` (not `overall_scores` or `overall_score`)
- 10 elements × 5 sub-elements = 50 max points

**Field Structure**:
```json
{
  "rubric": "rubric10-semantic",
  "version": "1.0",
  "project": "VOICE",
  "method": "claudecode_agent",
  "d4d_file": "data/d4d_concatenated/claudecode_agent/VOICE_d4d.yaml",
  "evaluation_timestamp": "2025-12-23T...",
  "model": {...},
  "summary_scores": {
    "total_score": 45,
    "total_max_score": 50,
    "overall_percentage": 90.0
  },
  "element_scores": [{...}, ...],  // 10 elements
  "semantic_analysis": {...},
  "recommendations": [...]
}
```

### 🔄 Task 3: Update Tools & Prompt (IN PROGRESS)

#### Required Updates:

1. **`scripts/fix_evaluation_scores.py`** - Needs modification
   - Add rubric10 support alongside rubric20
   - Handle `summary_scores` vs `overall_score` fields
   - Calculate from `element_scores[].sub_elements[].score` (rubric10)
   - Support both path patterns (rubric10_semantic and rubric20_semantic)

2. **`scripts/render_evaluation_html_rubric10_semantic.py`** - Check compatibility
   - Verify it matches new schema expectations
   - Test with conforming JSON

3. **Updated Prompt** - Required
   - Reference `src/download/prompts/rubric10_semantic_schema.json`
   - Include post-processing step with `fix_evaluation_scores.py`
   - Add schema validation step
   - Update example output structure

## Next Steps

### Immediate Actions Required:

1. **Extend `fix_evaluation_scores.py`** to support rubric10:
   ```python
   # Add rubric type detection
   rubric_type = eval_data.get("rubric") or (
       "rubric10-semantic" if "rubric10_semantic" in str(eval_path) else
       "rubric20-semantic" if "rubric20_semantic" in str(eval_path) else
       None
   )

   # Add rubric10 calculation
   if rubric_type == "rubric10-semantic":
       for element in eval_data.get("element_scores", []):
           for sub_elem in element.get("sub_elements", []):
               total_score += sub_elem.get("score", 0)
       # Fix summary_scores field

   # Keep existing rubric20 logic
   elif rubric_type == "rubric20-semantic":
       # existing code...
   ```

2. **Create updated prompt file** as replacement:
   - File: Replace the user's prompt with updated version
   - Include schema reference
   - Add validation requirements
   - Specify post-processing

3. **Test regeneration workflow**:
   - Generate one evaluation (e.g., CM4AI) using new prompt
   - Validate against `rubric10_semantic_schema.json`
   - Run `fix_evaluation_scores.py` on it
   - Generate HTML from result
   - Verify HTML displays correctly

### Files to Modify:

- [x] `src/download/prompts/rubric10_semantic_schema.json` - CREATED
- [ ] `scripts/fix_evaluation_scores.py` - NEEDS UPDATE
- [ ] User's rubric10 prompt - NEEDS COMPLETE REWRITE
- [ ] `scripts/render_evaluation_html_rubric10_semantic.py` - VERIFY COMPATIBILITY

### Validation Checklist:

Before regenerating all 4 projects:
- [ ] Schema JSON is valid (check with jsonschema validator)
- [ ] fix_evaluation_scores.py handles rubric10 format
- [ ] HTML renderer works with new structure
- [ ] Validation script exists/works
- [ ] Test with one project first (CM4AI)

## Reference Documents

- **Issue Report**: `RUBRIC10_ISSUES_REPORT.md`
- **Schema**: `src/download/prompts/rubric10_semantic_schema.json`
- **Output Format Example**: `src/download/prompts/rubric10_output_format.json`
- **Rubric20 Schema** (reference): `src/download/prompts/rubric20_semantic_schema.json`
- **HTML Renderer**: `scripts/render_evaluation_html_rubric10_semantic.py`

---

**Status**: Tasks 1-2 complete, Task 3 in progress
**Date**: 2025-12-23
**Next**: Update fix_evaluation_scores.py and create new prompt
